Straw Bale Vs Hay Bale Gardening

Straw bale gardening is HUGE! And for good reason as it's an easy way to grow vegetables and flowers in small spaces, driveways, or any area where it's hard to dig a new garden. A straw bale is a self-contained garden where the centre of the bale is seasoned with fertilizers to start the decomposition process and create a rich pocket for plants. Read on to learn more about gardening in straw bales.

growing vegetables on a trellis — A straw bale garden can be as simple as a single seasoned straw bale or it can include structures like trellises for vertical crops like tomatoes, peas, pole beans, and cucumbers.

Straw bale gardening has been popularized in recent years by Joel Karsten, the author of Straw Bale Gardens Complete, which details everything you need to know to get started growing in straw bales. I think many people have embraced this technique because it's so easy to do, straw is widely available, and it allows you to grow food in small spaces or less-than-ideal sites.

Straw versus hay

I'm often asked about the difference between straw and hay and which material is the best to use in a vegetable garden. Straw bales are comprised of the stems of grains like wheat and barley. They're often used as bedding for animals and gardeners use straw for mulching, composting, or straw bale gardening. Hay bales are made up the entire plant and therefore contain seed heads. They're used as feed for sheep, cows, and horses. Gardeners generally avoid hay as they don't want to introduce weedy seeds into their garden beds.

Benefits of straw bale gardening

While I enjoy growing vegetables in a handful of straw bales at the back of my food garden, they aren't a replacement for my raised beds. They are, however, a great way to get more out of my space. Here are 5 benefits to planting in straw bales:

Fewer weeds – While straw bales are made from stems of plants, I do find most contain some seed heads. As the summer progresses, those seeds may sprout into grassy weeds. I don't find this to be a big deal and just leave them to grow. The real benefit is that common garden weeds like lambs-quarters, dandelions, pigweed, and purslane aren't found in straw bales and therefore you won't spend the summer battling these aggressive weeds.
It's a cheap way to start a garden – Straw bales can run from $5 to $15 each in my area. I try to buy them in autumn, when they're easier and cheaper to source. It also pays to buy them from a farmer, not a garden centre, where they are typically less expensive.
No need to build a raised bed – I love my raised beds, but each one is a DIY project that requires time, tools, and money. If you're renting or not sure you want to commit to a permanent raised bed, planting a straw bale garden is a great way to grow food quickly.
Plant anywhere! – Do you have poor, rocky soil that is super hard to work? Make a straw bale garden. Is your only sunny spot a driveway or paved area? Make a straw bale garden. No time to dig up an area for an in-ground garden? Make a straw bale garden! Check out the picture below of Steven and Emma Biggs' wonderful straw bale driveway garden in urban Toronto.
Compost materials – At the end of the season, the spent straw from the half-rotted bales can be turned into compost.

squash planted in a straw bale — I love growing squash, pumpkins, and gourds in straw bales as they love all the nutrients and organic matter in the decomposing bales.

Types of straw bale gardens

While most straw bale gardens are made from whole, stringed straw bales, I also make free-formed straw bale beds to grow vegetables like squash, pumpkins, cucumbers, burr gherkins, melons, and gourds.

Stringed straw bales – This is the type of straw bale garden you see in books, magazines, and websites. The rectangular straw bales are held together with a string material, usually plastic twine.
Free-formed straw bale beds – I like to call this deconstructed straw bale gardening as I typically make these beds from old, half rotted straw bales or the straw that was used for mulching the season before. They're super easy to make and create a nutrient-rich bed for growing vegetables. I layer straw with rotted manure or compost so that there are two to three layers of each. I also add some slow-release organic fertilizer as I create the layers to ensure a rich mix.

Sourcing straw bales

Depending where you live, it can be hard to source straw bales. In my area, the cost per bale ranges from $5 to $15. The low range is when I buy them directly from a farmer. The higher cost comes from buying straw bales at garden centres. I also buy my bales in fall, not spring. Why? They're easier to source in the fall and the price is generally lower. I store the fresh, dry bales at the back of my polytunnel, in my shed, or under a sheet of plastic to prevent them from getting wet and waterlogged over the winter.

NOTE: When buying straw bales, be sure to ask if the straw was treated with an herbicide. Avoid any treated bales as they can't be used to grow a straw bale garden and they can contaminate your garden soil or compost pile.

straw bale garden in driveway — No space? No problem! Best-selling authors and father-daughter duo Steven and Emma Biggs grow tomatoes and other crops in straw bales in their driveway.

Where to put a straw bale garden

When growing vegetables, site selection is very important. Most vegetable crops need at least eight hours of full sun each day, especially those which produce fruits; tomatoes, squash, cucumbers, and peppers.

Keep in mind that a straw bale holds a lot of water and it's very heavy and awkward, if not impossible to move. So be sure your chosen location can host your straw bale garden for the entire season.

The beauty of straw bale gardening is that you can create a garden where it would be difficult to plant in-ground or even with a raised bed. Before putting the bales down, you can lay newspaper, cardboard, landscape fabric, or other materials underneath the bales to prevent weeds. My base is bark mulch so I don't bother but if your site is very weedy, this is a good idea.

Conditioning a straw bale for gardening

Once you've planned the design of your straw bale garden and gathered the bales, it's time to start the conditioning process. You can't plant directly into fresh, unconditioned bales as they don't offer the organic matter and nutrients that vegetable seedlings need to grow.

This process takes about two weeks, so plan accordingly and begin conditioning a few weeks before you intend to plant. Here are4 steps to conditioning straw bales:

Position the bales. This is an important step as the bales should be positioned so the narrow side with the visible cut straw edges is facing up. The hollow stems of the cut side help water (and the fertilizer during the conditioning process) fully saturate the entire bale. Also, don't remove the strings. They help the straw bale keep its shape as it decomposes over the summer months.
Apply two to three cups of organic fertilizer to the top of each bale every two days. I typically use what I have on hand which, this spring, was a bag of blood meal (high in N) and a general vegetable fertilizer. Water deeply to help the fertilizer work down into the bale.
Every second day – the day you don't fertilize – water each bale deeply. I like to take my garden fork to help loosen the tightly packed straw and allow the fertilizer work its way down into the bale.
After about 10 days, you'll notice the tops of the bales are beginning to break down. If you stick your hand into the bale – this is the cool bit – you'll likely feel that it's warm inside thanks to the composting process. At this point, I put two last cups of fertilizer on each bale and water thoroughly.

You can have fun with your straw bale garden designs. In their urban garden, Steven Biggs, the co-host of the Food Garden Life podcast has built a straw bale pepper pyramid with several different hot pepper varieties.

What kind of fertilizer to use in straw bale gardening

I use an organic fertilizer that is high in nitrogen. Avoid slow release fertilizers because you want the nitrogen to be readily available to jump-start the decomposition process. I use blood meal, but you could use other high nitrogen fertilizers like alfalfa meal, feather meal, or an organic lawn food.

Straw bale gardening instructions

Straw bale gardening is really easy. To sum it up, start by sourcing straw bales, then season them, plant with seedlings or seeds, and water and fertilizer throughout the summer. At the end of the season, you'll have plenty of organic material to toss in your compost pile.

To really take your straw bale garden to the next level, consider adding vertical supports like trellises, tunnels, or stakes. These should be secured to the ground and not just inserted in the straw bale which will rot as the season progresses. You can use strong metal, wood or fibreglass stakes, or various A-frame trellises to provide ample support to vining or vertical crops.

Once the trellises or supports are in place, plant indeterminate tomatoes, squash, pumpkins, melons, cucumbers, pole beans, and other climbing vegetables to scale the vertical structures.

garden bed ready to plant — Once your straw bales have been seasoned for two weeks, they're ready to plant. I add a thin layer of compost or soil to the top of my bales if I'm direct seeding. If you're transplanting, you don't need to add extra soil.

Care & maintenance

Once your straw bale garden is planted, the majority of the work is finished but you'll still need provide consistent moisture and fertilize.I like to water with a watering wand as it allows me to direct water at the base of the plants and the surface of the straw bale. Splashing water from a sprinkler can encourage the spread of common vegetable diseases so I avoid overhead watering. Alternatively, you can also run drip irrigation or soaker hoses at the top of the bales to provide a deep, regular watering.

You may have used a lot of fertilizer to season your straw bales but I still supplement that with a dose of a liquid organic feed every two to three weeks once the bales are planted. I like using fish emulsion, liquid kelp, or phytoplankton fertilizer in my watering can to give the plants a boost.And while you can expect fewer soil borne disease issues growing in straw bales you still need to keep an eye out for pests and disease issues like powdery mildew, squash bugs, and cucumber beetles.

squash plants — Once planted, keep your straw bales well watered and fertilize every two to three weeks with a liquid organic food.

Best plants for straw bale gardening

You can grow practically any vegetable in a straw bale, but some are easier to grow than others. Here are a few tips on picking the best plants for a straw bale garden:

I like to use straw bales to grow space hogging, nutrient-loving veggies like zucchini, pumpkins, gourds, and cucumbers. I have the perfect spot at the end of my raised bed vegetable garden where their vigorous vines can go crazy. Plus, they love the rich growing medium inside the composting straw bales.

If you wish to direct seed, I recommend adding a several inch deep layer of soil to the top surface of seasoned straw bales. You can then direct seed vegetables like beans, peas, squash, lettuce, kale, or cucumbers. For most crops, I prefer to transplant as it's quicker and less work.

While squash and pumpkins love straw bales, so do heat-loving vegetables like tomatoes, peppers, and eggplants. These can be transplanted once the risk of frost has passed in late spring.

Seed potatoes or sweet potato slips can be tucked in little holes you dig out from the top of the straw bales.

I generally don't plant root crops in straw bales as they grow far better in my raised beds. If you wish to plant root crops like carrots, beets, or radishes, top your straw bale with a few inches of soil and direct seed.

Straw bale gardening problems

While there are many advantages to straw bale gardening, I have encountered a few drawbacks and issues.

It's a garden that only lasts one year. You can recycle the half rotted straw into a free-formed bed in year two (see above) but after an entire growing season, most straw bales have collapsed and decomposed and can't be used for a second season.
You need a lot of fertilizer to season the bales for planting. I know some gardeners use inorganic, herbicide-free lawn fertilizers to season their straw bales. You can buy a large bag fairly cheap, but as an organic gardener I prefer to use an organic product and that can add up quickly.
Straw bales are big sponges and if the weather is dry, they need to be watered frequently.
Slugs are a nuisance in my garden, but particularly in my straw bale beds in late spring when the weather is still cool and damp. I hand pick every day and use a layer of diatomaceous earth around each plant to reduce damage.

kale and lettuce — In a winter greenhouse or polytunnel, hardy greens like kale can be planted in straw bales for cold season harvesting.

Straw bale gardening in winter

This is a fun project for those who have structures like greenhouse, polytunnels, or even geodesic domes. I often store straw bales in my polytunnel during winter so I can use them in spring for mulching and straw bale gardening. But, I've also used them to grow cold hardy greens like kale, spinach, Asian greens, and arugula for winter harvesting.

For mature kale plants, place the bales in your structure in mid-summer and begin the seasoning process. Once they're ready to plant, tuck four kale plants in each bale. By the time the cold weather arrives a few months later, your kale will be mature and you can harvest leaves for salads and kale chips from December until March.

For more information on growing food with straw or even shredded leaves, be sure to check out these articles below as well as the excellent book by Craig LeHoullier, Growing Vegetables in Straw Bales:

Check out this awesome interview with Joel Karsten from the Food Garden Life podcast
How to grow seed potatoes in the ground, in pots and in straw
A simple winter mulch equals a bumper crop of cold season veggies
From potato bins to squash rings, how to use leaves in the garden

Are you a straw bale gardener? Share your experiences in the comments below.

Learn how to grow vegetables in straw bales